If you look at last year's rankings:

Penny 101st in MLB
Valverde 75th

versus

Braun 18th
Guthrie 181st


Guthrie is a throw-away, so you basically traded a fantasy stud in Braun for two solid guys in Penny and Valverde. Nobody knows how things will turn out at this point, but you may regret this one if Braun stays healthy. I'm always confused when trying to figure in the Canadian exchange rate anyways...