I agree Aurora. One of those two did it, and I think it was the Low.

Low, how can you think I did it when there was no evidence (i.e. I left no posts with Roscoe's name in it)? That was what made me remove any lingering doubt it must be you. You must want me out of the way.

On the other hand, Prof either really believes it is Aurora or he wants her out of the way also.

Both cannot be killers, and since I left no evidence, you cannot believe I really did it. Therefore you are the killer and Prof must erroneously believe Aurora is guilty.

__________________
"Quite simply captain, I examined the problem from all angles, and it was plainly hopeless. Logic informed me that under the circumstances, the only logical action would have to be one of desperation. Logical decision, logically arrived at." -- Spock

Ok I have not yet weighed in on who comitted this heinous crime. Without a prolonged closing arguement I am saying the Professor did it.

I don`t quite understand the game yet but because the Prof posts are so deep anyway, he must have posted something that incriminates himself, I just don`t know which post or when.

The Professor, Guilty!!!!!!!

poll will close at 9 PM CST 10 EST and the accused murderer shall be hung for the heinous crime of off'ing the father of PF.com.

get your votes in.

__________________

Professor, I accuse you of the evil deed. I do not feel the evidence is very strong, and I almost chose The Low. You have only one post where you use the victim roscoe's name and have key basketball words of "offense" and "defensive."

The Low had three posts, all in the same thread however, where he used roscoe's name and the key basketball word of "jumpers" in two of them.

My head tells me that the murderer is The Low, but my gut tells me it's you. Your most recent attempt to further incriminate me by character assassination instead of sticking to the evidence is telling. So I chose you.

Also, I think that the keyword "jumpers" is really lame and probably not a basketball keyword.

I sure hope The Low isn't going to get away with murder. Professor, if I am wrong and you hang...the justice system in this game needs to be overhauled. An innocent man should not die over planet/basketball analogies. Evidentiary procedure will be reviewed I am sure (it's the first round, after all).

Now only dlev59 and warthog are left to decide our and The Low's fate.

Dlev forgot to vote in the poll! What now?

i voted to hang warthog because he never contributed to the mob.

__________________

I'll wait a few more minutes to allow dlev an 11th hour, life changing vote.


we have a 3 way tie. I never took that into account since it never happened in the parlor game version. i suppose I will need to get out the "Coin of Life and Death"

Just think, your lives depend of the landing of a peso. Doesn't that make you feel cheap.

__________________

ok the poll will remain open until 2 am because i was up late on thursday when i did the poll. however, tallying is complete.

Darth Tater
AuroraKMW
professor

we have a three way tie. your fates shall hang in the balance. Who will meet roscoe36 in the afterlife? I will post the results by tomorrow.

__________________

Oh oh. Prof just said in a "Tigers" thread that I pointed out something to him in another thread. I have to say that it wasn't me who pointed it out.

Is he setting me up as his next victim if neither of us is hanged.

I thought I'd better say something before he does it...I may be dead soon. Hopefully this keeps me alive.

Wait...I don't see a keyword in the post. Maybe I'm noid?

Dude, get some sleep. Its only a game.

__________________