I'm not sure about "top 5 SG material," but I do think you have made great improvements. Keep going to counseling, and keep your head up... things are looking better!
Yes, our evaluation tools are obviously vastly different. Because I consider consistency to be a pretty important factor. I live in Aus, so I haven't been able to catch all the games because of the time difference, but from what I have seen, Stuckey is certainly not a great defender.