Originally Posted by pistonsloyalist

Excellent analysis and summary, Mikhail.

In retrospect, it is too bad we released Carlos Pena, a first baseman/designated hitter, in early 2006.

Carlos showed real power in 2005, hitting 18 home runs as a part-time player (only 260 at bats). At one point late in the season when he was playing more regularly, I think he hit home runs in something like four out of five games. One of those home runs was one of the longest ever hit in Comerica Park.

This year, Pena has really blossomed for Tampa Bay. He has 42 home runs and 116 RBI's. We could have used that kind of production this year.

Originally Posted by ggazoo69

What does everyone think of Ryan Raburn? Is he better than just a bench player? Is the future outfield of the Tigers to be Raburn, Maybin and Granderson? Or am I reaching here?

Originally Posted by mikhail1973

I believe you're reaching. He'd be great off the bench since he can play multiple positions. But he's an average defender at best. I think he'll be around for a long time though because of the versatility.

Originally Posted by Murph

You know who the Tigers could really use at the top of their rotation next year? Johan Santana.

What would it take to land this guy? 6 years for $120 million?

Is Illich really committed to winning? Would he shell out that kind of money for Santana?

ESPN - Johan Santana Stats, News, Photos - Minnesota Twins - MLB Baseball

Originally Posted by mikhail1973

I don't think Tigers are going to give up top notch prospects to a rival.

Originally Posted by ggazoo69

Why not? If you had Santana, you wouldn't have to necessarily re-load the farm system as quickly.

The Twins would want an awful lot. And frankly, I don't think Ilitch wants any more big salaries. He's got Sheffield and Ordonez. Sheffield is being overpaid as it is.

Originally Posted by BillLaimbeer

Talk about Comeback Player of the Year. Pena had 1 HR last year. Tonight, he hit his 43rd HR of the season. Who'd of thunk it?